Please Apple, no camera in the iPad!
Yes, you read correctly and l know there will be some raised eyebrows, but let me explain.
Our school has recently become a part of the Victorian iPad Trial in Melbourne, Australia. We currently have up to 140 devices on a 1:1 program with our Years 4 & 5 students. They have access to the devices 24/7 and so far, the majority of the experience has been extremely positive.
As educators, one of our biggest priorities is keeping our children safe. While I used to be a bit skeptical, a 1:1 program provides the best opportunity for our students to learn the positive and negative aspects of technology. It provides our students with the chance to experience the power of the device, but also, and more importantly, the opportunity to guide them through what is a daunting new world.
In a real partnership with parents, primary/elementary schools have a chance at helping students to form responsible and safe habits when using technology, as well as empowering them to know what to do if something is not going as they would like. In my opinion, once you hit your teens, it is too late to start forming these habits.
I recently attended a Cybersafety information evening at my son’s school, presented by a friend who is a police officer and has worked in this specific area. I encourage all educators to attend one of these sessions run by a real officer with real scenarios. While I was aware of many of the issues, there were some that were real eye-openers, which also reiterated to me what an important responsibility we have when encouraging our students to utilise this technology.
He indicated one of the most difficult issues to control is the way in which adolescents are using the technology to share images. In saying that, imagine having to deal with the issues an in-built camera on the iPad will pose for schools? One silly photo taken and emailed, or uploaded to Facebook or YouTube = a digital tatoo for life!
While I sat in the presentation, confident the weekly sessions our school runs on Cybersaftey and the focus we have placed on informing our students and parents on their responsibilities, I was encouraged by the lack of a camera in the iPad. There are a number of ways students and teachers can share images for school work which can be accessed and used on the iPad, but the fact there is no camera immediately available on the device is was rather comforting.
Many schools utilising the in-built cameras on iPhones and iPods at school no doubt find them to be a welcome addition. But many of these devices are held by schools and returned at the end of the day. I would be interested to hear of any schools allowing students to have possession of such a device on a 24/7 basis and how they are managing them.
So, of course I see the benefits of an in-built camera in the iPad, but I encourage educators to stop and think of the implications it could have for the use of this device in schools. I think it is a topic worth reflecting on.
Have you considered the implications this feature could have on the students at your school?
Print article | This entry was posted by Adam on November 19, 2010 at 8:06 pm, and is filed under Mobile Learning. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
about 2 months ago
Well @ my secondary school they all have cameras in their pockets anyway. I had this discussion while on yard-duty the other day when I saw a bunch of Yr8′s with their phones out videoing some kids yahooing about. Some of them thought it was a basic right to video anything they want.
about 2 months ago
strange argument. does that mean you ban all phones from your school or access to any form of camera. Or is it just the instant ability to take a photo and then access the internet that concerns you? Or is it the ability to take photos at home that concerns you? Are you concerned that the devise has the ability to record audio as well. I am much more of a believer in open access to students to all equipment and as a school you take responsibility for setting up a positive environment… which it seems you are already doing. what happens at home is the environment for the parents to be concerned with and not so much a teachers role
about 2 months ago
Some good points Kynan. Thanks for your comment.
Not really an argument, I suppose, but just thinking that with so many schools looking at iPads as a 1:1 device in schools, the addition of a camera could raise issues for the school. I am in no way calling for the banning of cameras, simply putting out a reminder of what can happen if we are not vigilant or clear on expectations. Through experience, eMail has been something we are working very hard to promote the positive use of because it has so many benefits for our students to know how to use. Yet even with that, we need to closely monitor what our students are doing.
I know the school has worked really hard to establish a positive environment for the students, and have invited parents to be a big part of it. The ongoing challenge for us is to keep it positive, even if there are some challenging issues to deal with, because our students are learning to become responsible users of this technology.
The key point is when a school starts a 1:1 program and puts devices in hands for student use 24/7, there is still a certain amount of responsibility the school has to accept for promoting positive behaviour after school hours. We are relying on parents being informed and interested in their children’s activities, but that may not always be the case. A student bringing their own devices to school from home is quite different.